Summarized Review Highlights
Reindeer Lake Lodge and its associated outpost camps, particularly Reilly Lake, have earned a strong reputation among experienced fly-in anglers, with nearly all reviewers rating their stays at the top of the scale. Guests consistently describe the operation as professional and well-organized, with owners and staff going to notable lengths to ensure camps are well-maintained and fully equipped — even in circumstances such as reopening a long-dormant outpost camp following wildfire disruptions. The overall sentiment across reviews is one of genuine satisfaction, with multiple guests describing their trips as among the best fishing experiences they have had anywhere in northern Canada or internationally.
Fishing quality is the most consistently praised element, with pike drawing particular attention. Guests report frequent catches of trophy-sized northern pike in the 40-to-47-inch range, with walleye described as fast and plentiful, and lake trout available as a bonus species. Food and hospitality also receive strong praise, with the guided lodge experience noted for a structured daily schedule, quality meals made with fresh ingredients, and attentive staff. Camp attendants and guides are mentioned by name in several reviews and described as knowledgeable and quietly efficient. The remote setting on Reindeer Lake itself is highlighted as scenically impressive, with wildlife viewing and accessible side trips adding to the overall experience.
There are no recurring complaints across these reviews. One blogger noted that finding trophy pike at the self-guided Reilly outpost camp required patience and some trial and error, particularly early in the week, which is a realistic expectation for a do-it-yourself camp format. Travel time to reach the destination is significant — one international reviewer noted a 29-hour door-to-door journey — so the lodge is best suited to anglers who are prepared for a serious commitment of time and travel. Based on the reviews, this destination appeals most strongly to dedicated pike and walleye anglers chasing trophy-class fish, groups of experienced fishing buddies, and those with an interest in a true remote wilderness setting. The guided lodge experience suits anglers who appreciate structured hospitality in a remote environment, while the Reilly outpost camp is better suited to self-sufficient groups comfortable running their own camp and boats.
Summary generated May 25, 2026
Read all 14 reviews
Global740947 (Kerry and Carole Olsen)
Jul 7, 2023
TripAdvisor
Incredible fishing experience
My wife and I just returned from one of the best trips of our life - Arctic Lodges an amazing place - wild, beautiful, yet peaceful, with incredible fishing, Reindeer Lake is a treasure - caught well over 200 Northern Pike over 30 inches - many over 40! Gourmet food, excellent accommodations, skilled guides and a helpful, friendly, fantastic staff - incredible attention to all details combined to make a superb trip. I was there 61 years ago with my Dad - hope to bring some kids and grand kids next time. We will be back!
This lodge
jennybD1855LK
Oct 25, 2022
TripAdvisor
World Class Fishing Trip
My young son, brother, and I had the opportunity to fish and stay at the Arctic Lodge on Reindeer Lake in July 2022. The fishing was absolutely unbelievable. Grayling, Walleye, and Lake Trout were big and plentiful... but my focus was on 40 plus inch Northern Pike. We caught multiple fish over 40"! The cabins and lodge were rustic but very nice... and food were truly first class. The guides were professional and hard working... and made the best shore lunches I have ever had.
This lodge
Bertrand Ngim, Ph.D.
Aug 28, 2019
Blog
Western Canada's Reindeer Lake — A Once-in-a-Lifetime Trip
Reindeer Lake in Western Canada is such an awesome, world-class fishery that should be in every enthusiast angler's bucket list of places to fish. I have had an absolute blast there fishing with a group of anglers from Asia recently and was blown away by the outstanding quality of the fishery and my overall experience during my stay at Reindeer Lake Lodge. We were there in early July where spinnerbaits and swimbaits were the deal of the week both in terms of quality and numbers caught. In fact, the spinnerbait bite was truly outstanding that it enabled us to make the front cover on three angling magazines in Asia. I caught my personal best northern pike on a BBZ-1 60 (matte firetiger) in a backwater area — the fish measured 47 inches from nose to tail. Our guide, Robert Clarke is an awesome guy who knows all about starting fires and cooking in extremely windy conditions. The food and hospitality is top notch and the day's itinerary runs like clockwork. The day begins with breakfast at 7:00am, lunch midday, pre-dinner drinks 5.30pm and dinner at 7:00pm. The quality of food is superb! I am a foodie and I totally love the food at Reindeer Lake Lodge where they really go the extra mile to deliver you the best they can. It is hard for me to comprehend that the lodge, especially its remote location, even has a full-fledged kitchen and regular delivery of fresh food and produce. My journey from the United Kingdom spanned around twenty-nine hours door-to-door, but once you arrive at the lodge on that tranquil island, it is like you have stepped into a different world. In my opinion as an angler, this is truly a once in a lifetime trip that you ought to experience. If you are thinking or planning an angling vacation in Canada, I highly recommend that you check out Reindeer Lake Lodge.
This lodge
First Class Fly Fishing Experience
My wife and I just returned from a four-day trip to explore Reindeer Lake and Arctic Lodges as a fly fishing destination. What a great experience. Scenic beauty, wildlife, great accommodation, world class food, shore lunches (a true Canadian wilderness experience) and lots of large willing fish to challenge anyone. Northern pike, lake trout, grayling, lake whitefish and walleye all available for the fly fisher to pursue.
This lodge
Realityguy
Aug 24, 2017
TripAdvisor
Potluck.
I have picked a fishing location in Canada for 6 guys every summer for the last 25 years. Arctic has clean cabins, good food and very nice staff. However the fishing quality is almost entirely based upon the guide you get. Some people caught many northerns over 40 inches while some others caught just a few small northerns. We were there for 3 full days and one half day. There is no four day trip despite what they say. Our last day we spent 6 hours driving around in the boat and 2 hours fishing. When I said something to management they could have cared less. Water, soda and alcohol are very expensive. The place does have potential but the fishing is not in same class as Wollaston lake lodge to the north. (Owner responded Jan 2018 disputing the bar pricing and the first-day schedule.)
This lodge
Brian G
Jul 20, 2017
TripAdvisor
Trip of a lifetime
Incredible experience. I was expecting an extremely rustic experience and I was wrong. The fishing is obviously incredible, my wife and I are not exactly amazing fisher-people and we probably caught ~50 large fish a day. The staff works really hard to get on a first name basis quickly and is incredibly accommodating. Our guide was great and had decades of experience on reindeer lake, was funny and made a great shore lunch every day. Breakfast and dinner were also top notch. The lodge is a great gathering spot and the rooms have hot water, toilets, fresh towels and sheets daily.
This lodge
Steve Y
Dec 6, 2016
TripAdvisor
Great Place
Arctic Lodges is a great experience. Lots and lots of big pike. I've been there twice now and between my partner and I we have boated over northern over 40" for 8 days of fishing and hundreds of smaller fish. The lodge self is beautiful and very comfy. The cabins themselves are rustic which I enjoy. The food is very good and the staff is awesome. Kelly and Andrea do a great job making sure that their guests have a great time. This is now an annual trip for me!
This lodge
Anniversary Trip ...
Bob & I had the most wonderful 5 day mini holiday at Arctic Lodges. The place is extremely remote and not only did we enjoy the flight but once we landed the place was magic. The staff were all out to greet us & a scrumptious brunch was laid out by the Chef. Our private little cabin was rustic but spotlessly clean & tidy with a hand made anniversary card & a bottle of bubbly on the table. Our guide was George & what a gentleman. We did catch our share of fish, some of which George prepared for shore lunches.
This lodge
Sixth trip and Counting
If you like fishing, wonderful scenery, great shore lunches and top quality meals at the lodge you really should plan a trip to Arctic Lodges. My two sons and I have made the trip six out of the last seven years travelling from Chicago. Last year we caught and released several trophy pike including a 48" and 45". With over 5000 islands the scenery is really beautiful on Reindeer Lake. The boats are very comfortable. Log cabins for the guests are comfortable. Breakfasts and dinners have been very good every year. Andrea and Kelly really do try to make everyone's trip memorable.
This lodge
Arctic Lodge!! WOW!
What an excellent week at Arctic Lodges on Reindeer Lake, Saskatchewan. We caught too many Northern pike to count. Most over 35 inches and my personal best of 41.5. We caught arctic Grayling and lake trout as well. Our guide Luca was absolutely the best and his shore lunch pike was awesome. The staff at Arctic Lodge is amazing. Great breakfast and dinner each day and the cabins are perfect. I'll definitely be going back! (Stay: June 2024)
This lodge
Outstanding Stay at Reindeer Lake Lodge
Our whole group agrees ... our stay at Reindeer Lake Lodge was outstanding. Once again... thank you for a wonderful week.
This lodge
I have fished Reindeer lake's Lawrence Bay Lodge in mid-August for several years. We fly into Saskatoon and drive to Southend where the Lodge's float plane picks us up. The pike and Laker fishing is great. We've caught several pike of 50" or more. The lodge's cost is reasonable.
This lake
Problem solving service
This review is a bit different. My 3 daughters and I wanted to visit an island in Reindeer Lake named after my Grandfather. The plan was to fly to Bray island via Lawrence Bay Airways, camp 4 nights on the island, fly back out and drive to our home in Regina. Too Smokey to fly in so Randy offered to boat us to the lodge where we could stay the night and boat the rest of the way to Bray Island the next morning. We took his offer, had a wonderful evening and meals and a great 2 hour boat ride up to the island with Vince Bear one of the fishing guides. We had a glorious time on the island for two days but then a bear changed our plans. With a couple of encounters we decided we had to leave. Phil and Vince to the rescue. Vince arrived at the island at 10:30pm. Loaded up his boat and then a two hour ride through the night expertly guided by Vince back to the lodge. Again, accommodations provided at a moments notice. Next day we went fishing. My daughters had a great time and we all enjoyed the great shore lunch provided by Vince and Darwin. Next day Randy took us back to Southend where we planned to camp and then head home. Campground was closed so we decided to go to La Ronge. 15 minutes into the trip – flat tire – but Marc the float plane pilot was right behind us and he took control of the situation which was more than just a simple tire change. Ended staying at his quarters overnight before finally heading home to Regina. A crazy adventure but the crew at Lawrence Bay Lodge and Airways were amazing. Thanks to Randy, Phil, Vince and Darwin and other staff our experience will be remembered for a lifetime.
This lake
We spent 4 days fishing on reindeer lake with Lawrence Bay Lodge. In those 4 days, I caught more fish than I have in the last 5 years! The hospitality we received from the staff at the Lodge was fantastic! The food we had every night at the Lodge and the shore lunches while out fishing were spectacular! The guide did an outstanding job getting us on fish all day long. This is truly an outstanding experience and I will most certainly be back for more!
This lake
Boats & Equipment
