Summarized Review Highlights
Guests describe Aylmer Lake Lodge in very positive terms. Nearly every review gives 5 out of 5 stars, and one gives 4. Many call it a "trip of a lifetime," and a number say they hope to return. A guide with 19 years of experience on lake trout waters across northern Canada said he had not seen more consistent or spectacular fishing. Another reviewer called it one of his favorite places to fish in the world.
Reviewers consistently praise the lake trout fishing, citing numbers, size, and the chance at a "monster." One father-and-son pair reported dozens of fish in the 10-20 lb class, at least a dozen between 20 and 30 lb, and five over 30 lb in four days, many on fly rods. Other guests mention personal-best fish, including a 31 lb trout, and arctic grayling. One angler was surprised to catch lakers on a spoon. Guests also like the lodge itself, describing the cabins as comfortable, clean, warm and dry, and one called it the best accommodation they had had in the tundra. The food and chef (Frances is named) are called excellent or top notch. Guides, including Nate/Nathan, and the hosts Kevin and Patti McNeil are described as hardworking, accommodating, and hospitable, with a family-lodge feel. Several reviewers mention the scenery and remoteness, and one said they enjoyed the camaraderie. One review notes that Kevin and Patti honored a pandemic-delayed booking at no extra cost.
Complaints are almost absent. The only caveat comes from the 4-star review, where a group faced tough weather and the fishing was on and off. That reviewer still thought the lake has great potential for 50 lb-plus fish. This is a remote Arctic location, so weather can affect fishing. The reviews suggest the lodge suits trophy lake trout anglers, fly-rod anglers, father-son and group trips, and first-time visitors to the Northwest Territories or the Arctic who want comfortable lodging in a remote setting. One guest said the trip felt more like a vacation than a fishing trip.
Summary generated Oct 11, 2026
Read all 20 reviews
David Clendening (Apple Valley, MN)
Nov 26, 2023
Outfitter
Booked a trip with Aylmer Lake Lodge in June 2020 for July 2021; a Canada travel ban was still in place, and Kevin and Patti honored the booking until July 2022 at no extra cost. Lake trout fishing was unbelievable, way past expectations for me and my son. We both caught our personal best lake trout on a fly rod: dozens in the 10-20 lb class, at least a dozen between 20-30 lb, and 5 over 30 lb in 4 days. The lodge is very comfortable with great vistas, the food was excellent, and Kevin and Patti run an extremely remote lodge like a family lodge experience. I highly recommend Aylmer Lake Lodge.
This lodge
First trip to NWT. You made the good times better. You and your crew were great. They work hard.
Outfitter overall
This is one of my favorite places to fish in the world. My biggest lake trout had been 13 pounds; this trip I broke my personal record with a 31 pound fish.
Outfitter overall
Kevin – Thank you and your team for an incredible fishing experience in the Arctic! My first visit to such a pristine area of the world – a true gem. Fishing is AMAZING and the scenery is indescribable. Thanks for your hospitality.
Outfitter overall
Thanks for a great adventure in the far north! Great once in a lifetime experience with so many beautiful fish. Great food from the chef. Thanks to Nathan the guide – was so great.
Outfitter overall
A great job by Kevin and his staff. Comfortable, clean warm and dry cabins. Beautiful pristine natural beauty! The great fishing is a huge bonus! I had a great week of adventure and restful sleeping.
Outfitter overall
Great water. Our group had some tough weather conditions so fishing was on and off. My feeling is that Aylmer Lake has great potential and many 50 pound plus fish will be caught. Look forward to coming back – great staff!
This lake
Good food. Great weather. Kevin's group was very accommodating. Had a great time!
Outfitter overall
Wow! What a fishery! Compliments to chef Frances as well. Thank you for an awesome experience. You and your team did a great job hosting our group. I hope to return.
Outfitter overall
In 19 years of guiding lake trout across major bodies of water around northern Canada, I have not experienced more consistent and spectacular fishing. The Lodge and professional staff are exemplary!
Outfitter overall
Fantastic country. Fishing is great – lots of fish and good size. This was more of a vacation than a fishing trip. Best fishing guide I ever had. These people really know how to run a hunting and fishing camp.
Outfitter overall
Had a great time! Hospitality was awesome. Nate was a great guide. Hope to make it back.
Outfitter overall
Awesome! Awesome! Awesome! The McNeils have hit a grand slam! Will be back!
Outfitter overall
Thanks Kevin and crew. Best accommodations I've had up in the tundra. Great fishing with the opportunity to catch a monster. Caught my biggest trout.
Outfitter overall
I have fished for lakers in northern Manitoba, but never in NWT. The fishing and accommodations were phenomenal. Never thought I would have caught lakers from a spoon. Food at the lodge was top notch. Can't wait to come back!
Outfitter overall
Kevin – thanks for everything. Trip of a lifetime. Enjoyed the camaraderie. Beautiful and wild country. Great food, guides and HUGE fish.
Outfitter overall
Thanks for a great trip and all the fellowship – the fishing was great! Good luck with the place and I hope to come back another day.
Outfitter overall
Great time and beautiful place! Great fishing sitting on top of the world. Wonderful people and hosts!
Outfitter overall
Great fishing. Beautiful landscape. Everyone worked hard to make our trip a success. We all had a wonderful time – especially learning a lot about the great Northwest. An experience I will never forget.
Outfitter overall
Aden Dunning (Outdoor Adventure Film Producer)
Outfitter
My son and I took a trip up to Aylmer Lake Lodge this summer. If you are looking for a remote fly in fishing experience in one of the most beautiful places on Earth and fish pristine waters for huge lake trout and arctic grayling, then I highly recommend this lodge for a trip of a lifetime.
This lodge