Aylmer Lake Lodge

Guests describe Aylmer Lake Lodge in very positive terms. Nearly every review gives 5 out of 5 stars, and one gives 4. Many call it a "trip of a lifetime," and a number say they hope to return. A guide with 19 years of experience on lake trout waters across northern Canada said he had not seen more consistent or spectacular fishing. Another reviewer called it one of his favorite places to fish in the world.

Reviewers consistently praise the lake trout fishing, citing numbers, size, and the chance at a "monster." One father-and-son pair reported dozens of fish in the 10-20 lb class, at least a dozen between 20 and 30 lb, and five over 30 lb in four days, many on fly rods. Other guests mention personal-best fish, including a 31 lb trout, and arctic grayling. One angler was surprised to catch lakers on a spoon. Guests also like the lodge itself, describing the cabins as comfortable, clean, warm and dry, and one called it the best accommodation they had had in the tundra. The food and chef (Frances is named) are called excellent or top notch. Guides, including Nate/Nathan, and the hosts Kevin and Patti McNeil are described as hardworking, accommodating, and hospitable, with a family-lodge feel. Several reviewers mention the scenery and remoteness, and one said they enjoyed the camaraderie. One review notes that Kevin and Patti honored a pandemic-delayed booking at no extra cost.

Complaints are almost absent. The only caveat comes from the 4-star review, where a group faced tough weather and the fishing was on and off. That reviewer still thought the lake has great potential for 50 lb-plus fish. This is a remote Arctic location, so weather can affect fishing. The reviews suggest the lodge suits trophy lake trout anglers, fly-rod anglers, father-son and group trips, and first-time visitors to the Northwest Territories or the Arctic who want comfortable lodging in a remote setting. One guest said the trip felt more like a vacation than a fishing trip.